Anna Maria Island, a cozy slice of paradise nestled along the west coast of Florida, boasts sun-kissed white sand, teal-blue waters, and an elegant culinary scene perfect for foodies from all corners of the world.
From fresh-off-the-boat seafood to innovative gourmet fare, dining on Anna Maria Island is truly an escapade in and of itself.
As you dine, breathe in the gentle ocean breeze and let the flavors of the beachside community whisk you away to a culinary wonderland.
Embark on a journey with me as we explore the top 5 best restaurants on Anna Maria Island and discover mouthwatering dishes, warm hospitality, and an unmatched dining experience.
1. The Waterfront Restaurant
A Historic Relic Turned Culinary Masterpiece
Tucked away in an early 20th-century beach house, The Waterfront Restaurant offers a perfect blend of history, flavor, and ambiance.
Originally built in 1922, this former home still retains its original charm, with a wraparound porch and stunning bay views that create a magical backdrop for an unforgettable dining experience.
Ambiance
Relish the old Florida charm as you ease into the cozy, candlelit atmosphere, highlighted by soft jazz music playing in the background.
Dine al fresco on the heated, covered patio overlooking the bay, or cozy up indoors among vintage furnishings and lush greenery.
Food Quality
A true culinary oasis, The Waterfront Restaurant showcases the best of locally-sourced ingredients with a contemporary twist.
Be sure to indulge in the Grouper Piccata, or the New Zealand Elk Rack served with a blackberry reduction.
Service
Expect nothing but warm and genuine service from The Waterfront staff, as they go above and beyond to ensure your meal is nothing short of perfection.
Unique Features
The extensive wine list from wineries around the world provides the perfect global touch to an exceptional Floridian dining experience.
2. Blue Marlin Seafood
A Fisherman’s Delight in the Heart of Anna Maria Island
Imagine a quaint, historic fishing cottage filled with unmatched Southern hospitality, and you have the essence of Blue Marlin Seafood.
Ambiance
Nestled in an early 20th-century home, diners will adore Blue Marlin’s intimate dining spaces adorned with warm wood and nautical decor, or take in the outdoors in the charming courtyard under twinkling lights and swaying palm trees.
Food Quality
Revel in the delectable seafood dishes exquisitely prepared to highlight fresh, locally-sourced bounty.
Opt for the Crab Stuffed Shrimp, or dive into their famous Fish Pot Pie, a dish not to be missed.
Service
The attentive and friendly staff cater to your every need and make dining at Blue Marlin Seafood a truly memorable experience.
Unique Features
The Trap Yard, a separate open-air dining area, features live music and gives diners a tantalizing glimpse of an authentic Anna Maria Island evening beneath the stars.
3. Three Oyster Bar & Grill
A Perfect Balance of Coastal Cuisine and Artisanal Fare
If you’re looking for the perfect balance between coastal cuisine and artisanal fare, look no further than Three Oyster Bar & Grill.
Located on the northern tip of Anna Maria Island, Three Oyster offers guests inspiring views and unique flavors.
Ambiance
The inviting atmosphere of Three Oyster radiates with a comfortable, beachy vibe, taking you away to a tropical paradise.
Enjoy the expansive outdoor seating area while gazing at the breathtaking sunset over the Gulf of Mexico.
Food Quality
Three Oyster’s menu is an exploration of craft cooking, featuring fresh seafood dishes such as Cedar Key Clams and Grilled Mahi Mahi alongside delectable appetizers like Roasted Garlic Mussels.
Service
With its highly trained staff, Three Oyster Bar & Grill offers attentive service that elevates your experience from good to exceptional.
Unique Features
Take advantage of their weekly specials including “Wine Wednesday”, which features a unique selection of wines from around the world.
Also, don’t forget to check out their craft beer flights, featuring a rotating selection of local brews.
For the perfect combination of coastal dining and artisanal fare, Three Oyster Bar & Grill is your first stop for a culinary adventure on Anna Maria Island.
Hours of Operation:
Mon-Thurs 11:30 am – 9 pm, Fri & Sat 11:30 am – 10 pm, Sun 11:30 am – 9 pm. Closed on Tuesdays.
4. Sandbar Restaurant
Fresh Seafood and Spectacular Sunsets Make for the Perfect Anna Maria Island Dining Experience
Sandbar Restaurant has been a favorite among locals and visitors alike for its beautiful sunsets, delicious seafood dishes, and laid-back atmosphere.
Located just steps away from the powdery white sands of Anna Maria Island, Sandbar is the perfect spot to unwind after a day at the beach.
Ambiance
Entering Sandbar’s dining room is like stepping into an oasis of calm and relaxation.
The simple, beachy decor creates a laidback atmosphere that instantly transports you to the serenity of the island’s waters.
Food Quality
Fresh seafood is the star of Sandbar’s menu, with delectable dishes such as their Lobster Ravioli and Shrimp & Grits—all made with locally-sourced ingredients.
Service
The friendly staff always ensures that guests feel welcomed and taken care of while they enjoy their meal in paradise.
Unique Features
Sandbar’s outdoor seating provides breathtaking views of the sun setting over the Gulf of Mexico, making it a perfect spot for picture-perfect moments during your stay on Anna Maria Island.
Hours of Operation:
Sun – Thurs 11 am – 8 pm, Fri & Sat 11 am – 9 pm
5. Gulf Drive Café & Tiki
Authentic Floridian Flair With a Stunning View of the Gulf Water
Gulf Drive Café & Tiki is a casual, beach-side eatery serving up classic American dishes with an authentic Floridian flair.
Located on Anna Maria Island’s north end and just steps away from the powdery white sands of the Gulf beaches, this café offers guests sweeping views of the beach and spectacular sunsets over the water.
Ambiance
The inviting atmosphere inside Gulf Drive Café & Tiki radiates warmth and comfort, taking you away to a relaxing island retreat.
The simple yet elegant décor adds to the cozy beach vibe that makes dining here feel like coming home.
Food Quality
Featuring classic American dishes with a Floridian twist, Gulf Drive Café & Tiki’s menu offers something for everyone.
Enjoy signature favorites such as their Grouper Sandwich and Oyster Po’ Boy alongside delicious appetizers like Coconut Shrimp.
Service
The friendly staff always ensures that guests feel welcomed and taken care of while they enjoy the spectacular island views from the outdoor seating area.
Unique Features
Gulf Drive Café & Tiki also offers an extensive selection of craft beers, wines, and cocktails—the perfect accompaniment to your waterfront dining experience.
Hours of Operation:
Sun – Fri 11 am – 9 pm, Sat 10 am – 9 pm. Closed on Mondays.